You are currently viewing How To Get Reviews On Etsy

How To Get Reviews On Etsy

For many Etsy sellers, negative reviews are a major concern. These reviews can significantly affect your shop’s reputation and sales. However, there are effective ways to minimize the chances of receiving negative feedback, as well as strategies to increase the number of positive reviews. This post aims to provide you with specific, actionable advice to achieve this balance. By implementing these tips, you can enhance your shop’s standing on Etsy and build a more positive customer experience. Let’s dive into these strategies and help your shop thrive.

The Etsy review system

Before we dive into the strategies, let’s first summarize how Etsy reviews work. Reviews can only be left by users who have actually made a purchase from your shop, including guest users. A review can be submitted within 100 days of the estimated delivery date. In the event of an order cancellation, the customer can still leave a review, but this time within a 48-hour period.

The core of the review is the star rating, which ranges between 1 and 5 stars, with 5 being the highest. Your shop’s rating is the average of all the stars received in the last 12 months.

In addition to the star rating, customers can leave written comments and attach pictures, providing more detailed feedback. It’s important to note that users can update their reviews at any point. However, once you, the seller, respond to a review, it becomes locked, meaning it can’t be modified further.

As a seller, you have the ability to publicly respond to all reviews, whether positive or negative. This feature is a powerful tool for expressing gratitude for good reviews or addressing any issues highlighted in less favorable ones.

The importance of Etsy reviews for your business

5-stars reviews

Reviews are one of the most important aspects of your Etsy shop. Having an outstanding shop rating can help with:

Building trust: Positive reviews serve as a testament to the trustworthiness and quality of your brand, encouraging customers to feel confident in their purchases.

Influencing purchases: They play a crucial role in convincing potential buyers to make a purchase, acting as persuasive testimonials of your product’s value.

Boosting visibility: A high shop rating can improve your Etsy SEO, enhancing your visibility in search results and attracting more traffic to your shop.

Qualifying for Star Seller: Maintaining a high shop rating is essential for eligibility in the Etsy Star Seller program, which can further elevate your shop’s prestige.

Getting valuable feedback: Reviews that offer constructive feedback are invaluable for refining your products and business practices, guiding you towards better customer satisfaction.

On the other hand, having a low shop rating can have detrimental effects on your shop’s success, potentially leading to reduced visibility and sales, and in extreme cases, may even threaten the continuation of your Etsy shop.

Strategies for getting more 5-star reviews

Earning 5-star reviews on Etsy doesn’t happen by chance; it requires strategic efforts and attention to detail. Here are some effective strategies to boost your chances of receiving those top ratings:

Ensure high product quality: The cornerstone of positive reviews is the quality of your products. Make sure that each item meets the high standards and reflects the craftsmanship your customers expect.

Deliver exceptional customer service: Elevate your customer service above expectations. Respond swiftly, clearly, and politely, using proper grammar and punctuation. Outstanding service can often turn a good review into a great one.

Surprise with packaging and presentation: The way you package and present your products can significantly influence customer perception. Thoughtful, attractive packaging can enhance the unboxing experience, leading to more positive reviews.

Follow up with customers: Proactively reach out to customers after their purchase. A follow-up message checking their satisfaction not only shows you care but also allows you to address any issues before they might result in a negative review.

Offer personalized experiences: Small personalized touches, like custom notes or packaging, leave a lasting impression. These details can delight customers and prompt them to share their positive experiences in reviews.

Strategies for avoiding negative reviews

Navigating customer feedback on Etsy is a delicate balance. To maintain a positive reputation and prevent negative reviews, consider these key strategies:

Implement a return policy: In the realm of online shopping, where physical examination of products isn’t possible, having a return policy is essential. The lack of such a policy may deter buyers, fearing they might be stuck with items that don’t meet their expectations. This apprehension could lead to negative reviews if customers find themselves unable to return products that don’t satisfy them. Especially for non-custom items, implementing a return policy can actually boost sales more than it results in actual returns.

Beware of scammers: Scammers are increasingly common on Etsy. These individuals may exploit return policies or fabricate issues to gain undue advantages. One effective way to protect your shop is by using tools like the Free Etsy Buyer Check tool, which allows you to review the past feedback and behavior of potential buyers. By staying vigilant and informed, you can safeguard your shop against fraudulent activities and ensure a more secure and positive selling experience.

free etsy buyer check

Respond quickly to customer queries: Fast and effective responses, particularly regarding order issues, are essential in preventing bad reviews. Prompt replies with solutions can transform a potentially negative experience into a positive one.

Be honest about your products: Be transparent about your products, highlighting both their strengths and weaknesses. Use clear, comprehensive photos and detailed descriptions to avoid unpleasant surprises for the customer. Misrepresenting products can lead to disappointment and negative reviews.

Provide tracking for shipments: Opt for shipping methods that include tracking. Cheap, untracked shipping can result in lost or delayed packages, leaving you to choose between issuing refunds or facing negative reviews. Tracking offers security for both you and your customers.

Ship all orders on time: Timely shipping is vital in maintaining customer satisfaction. Delayed shipments can lead to frustration and negative reviews. By ensuring your products are shipped as per the promised timeline, you reduce the risk of customer dissatisfaction. If you need to delay an order, make sure to contact the customer to inform them, and be prepared for the possibility that they may cancel their order.

Strategies for handling negative reviews

Dealing with negative reviews on Etsy can be challenging, but handling them correctly is crucial for maintaining your shop's reputation.

Dealing with negative reviews on Etsy can be challenging, but handling them correctly is crucial for maintaining your shop’s reputation. Here are some strategies to effectively manage and respond to negative feedback:

Pause before responding: Receiving a bad review, especially one that’s rude or hurtful, can be shocking. It’s important to take a moment and not respond immediately. An emotional response can be counterproductive. Plus, replying right away locks the review, eliminating any chance of the customer updating it later.

Offer a solution: After receiving a negative review, it’s advisable to reach out to the customer privately and offer one or two solutions to their issue. Good customer service often has the power to turn a negative review into a positive one. Rather than directly asking the customer to remove their review, which can increase their annoyance, focus on resolving their problem effectively. This approach usually leads to them updating their review.

Learn and improve: Sometimes negative reviews hold valuable insights. Reflect on the feedback and consider how your business can improve. Adapting your practices based on legitimate criticism can prevent future disappointments.

Polite public response: If the issue can’t be resolved privately, respond to the review publicly in a polite and professional manner. Focus your response on future customers, showing them that you take feedback seriously and are committed to continuous improvement.


In the dynamic world of Etsy, managing reviews is a vital aspect of running a successful shop. By implementing strategies to garner positive feedback, addressing customer concerns proactively, and thoughtfully handling negative reviews, you can significantly enhance your shop’s reputation. Remember, each review is an opportunity to showcase your commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. With consistent effort and a focus on exceptional service, your Etsy shop can thrive, building a loyal customer base and standing out in the marketplace. Keep striving for those 5-star reviews, and watch your Etsy journey flourish!

Leave a Reply